I would expect the BMW to be a better track car but a few observations: The F seems to pull pretty hard on the BMW off the line even though the in-car video of the F shows the driver having to back off a few times to get traction, also noticed several shifts by the F driver to be rather sloppy holding it to long round 7K RPM between shifts. Again, not surprised by the result but some of it could also be due to the driver as well. In the end both are great cars with each designed to providing a unique character and experience. I also own a 06' BMW Z4 M Roadster and bought the F for that exact reason and LOVE them both!!